City’s Integrity Commissioner appealing judge’s decision in Pearce Case

Elliot Lake’s former Integrity Commissioner has filed an appeal of a Superior Court judge’s decision in respect to a Municipal Conflict of Interest Act application against Councillor Ed Pearce.

City CAO Daniel Gagnon says back in March Justice Edward Gareau determined that Pearce had an indirect pecuniary interest when he voted on a matter at council, stating it contravened the statute but that he should not be removed from office.

However, the Integrity Commissioner, E4M Incorporated, has taken the position that the reprimand ordered by Justice Gareau is not equal to the nature and scale of the breach of the statute.

Gagnon says the IC is an independent officer of council and has the authority and discretion to pursue applications against sitting councillors under the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act with council or the city having no control.

He adds the city carries the obligation to pay for all legal expenses of the IC and Pearce to pay for his legal defence.

Gagnon says there are no additional details available regarding the appeal timing or process.

Justice Gareau’s reasons for his decision can be found at


PHOTO: Elliot Lake councillor Ed Pearce is being brought to court for a breach of the Municipal Conflict of Interest Act, not by the council or the city, but by the former Integrity Commissioner which does not agree with the findings of the court. Photo by Rosalind Russell

This entry was posted in Local, News. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *